Time to Kill:
The Blind Watcher Maker’s argument hit the scene in 1802 and has
been considered a way to describe the belief in an intelligent designer of the
universe. The argument in its simplistic form goes as follows: If you were to
take a pleasant walk in a forest, or mountain trail. Then upon taking a short
break you were to find a golden pocket watch at the base of your feet. The
reasoning follows it must have been created by an intelligent creature, for
surely no watches exist in nature, fully formed with its intricate gears,
springs, or whatever mechanisms hide within its golden body. The logic is then
extended to the greater universe.
This argument is meant to reveal the contrast of seemingly chaotic
nature and a constructed object, requiring intention, intelligence, and
production. We have never seen a bird or tree create a watch, nor express any
interest in owning one. A crow might inspect the object and appreciate its
golden shell.
The question of how the watch found its resting place in the
forest may have a long and complex story, but at some point, the watch had to
be calibrated. Blueprints had to be drawn up, measurements made, and small
tools used to craft the precise and intricate nature of the watch. This process
could have taken any length of time, and in the argument of the Blind
Watchmaker, these questions reveal the apparent difference between a
constructed object and the mundane dirt and leaves.
However, the criticism of this argument begins with the distinct
of what makes a watch a watch. To be considered a watch of any kind,
time-telling must be visible. If the gold object is merely a replica, then the
argument is about the appearance of distinction, and the illusion of a watch is
only a glamour.
If the essence of a watch is the ability to tell time, then the
natural world is full of such timepieces. The sun for example was worshipped
for thousands of years, not only for its life-giving rays for a healthy harvest,
but for determining geometry. Cultures have told time by the passing of moons,
the motion of tides, changing of season, migration of animals, and other such
predictable natural phenomena.
With the ability to accurately describe segments of time, and
geometry to describe the surface objects, ancient societies could produce great
feats of construction. In our modern age, such knowledge is trivial. We have
measuring tape, protractors, plastic squares, plums, laser levels, and other
technological shortcuts. Correct measurements adequately predict construction
timelines, and therefor a quality of social rulership; predictable jobs or
tasks.
A good ruler would be able to predict how much food would be
required for a workforce, and how many hours and people required for the task.
If the measurement of time was incorrect or the angle of the construction off
by a couple degrees, your pyramid would be an embarrassment; an error of divine
rulership. For example: the Egyptians made pyramids at a 41-degrees, except the
bent pyramid at 54 degrees, which suffered from shallow slope, and then
corrected to a steeper angle of 43 degrees.
Geometry and time-telling are also connected through the
understanding of the stars. A ship navigator or ancient astrologer could follow
the morning star of Venus and its endless pentagrams. A contemporary project
manager of a skyscraper has to include timelines for workers in hours and days.
However, time-telling is imperfect. Even the day and night of the
modern era is different than its primordial past. Since the creation of oceans,
and the moon, the hours of the day have increased 6 hours. This is due to tidal
locking, a mechanism of exchanging angular momentum between the moon and the
earth through the ocean, and in 2.4 million years the earth will cease rotation
exposing a face of the earth to the unrelenting sun. This distant future is
calculated on the decreased rotation of 15 milliseconds annually; an exact and
presence measurement. This is meant to show that time-telling is in fact a
common and mundane process done by endless reference points in the world, and a
watch being found in a forest is a matter of modern culture rather than a
quality of the watch itself. A watch would never be found in the forest during
600 BCE, you might however find a stone with astrological markings from the
decline of the Egyptian kingdom, something discarded in the fury of looting
burial chambers.
The ability to see the design in an object is a cognitive ability.
It is an ability which comes from many years of neuron development, pattern
recognition, and indicators of familiar construction. If the object was not a
watch but rather an alien object, with components of unknown production, we
would consider it an even more unnatural occurrence. Quartz for example is not
considered designed, yet its crystalline body has been a part of contemporary
watches for many years. When the argument was expressed in 1802, there were no
quartz watches, or digital watches. The details of what is considered a
familiar construction could be smeared to the point where a golden pocket is veiled
in ancient mystery, without sharp contrast to the world around it.
The watch may still seem out of place in the forest, especially
since we cannot see the connection from its origin to its resting place by our
feet on the trail.
If we knew there was a factory of watch construction nearby or
lived by a family of watch makers who regularly walk in the forest, our
narrative instinct wouldn’t even pause a moment, we would fill in the unknown
gap without hesitation or question.
I am arguing that the appearance of design, intention and
construction from an intelligence creature is indistinguishable from the
unknown. The watch maker, the watch, and the feeling of obvious intention is
superficial, and will dissolve upon any inspection. To illustrate this, I would
like to point out the purpose, the design of a piece of wood.
A piece of lumber could be crafted into a rocking chair, a table
leg, a or thrown on a fire for warmth. Describing any specific design as its
sole purpose is an observation of potential. When an object has no other
potential, we feel confident in its purpose, we have reduced it to simple
clarity, collapsed the myriad of possibility down to a single function, like the
function of time-telling for the pocket watch.
To say a pocket watch is separate from the forest is not a
conclusion or observation about the watch but a reflection of our perception,
our conceit of what we have created. In closing, it is grandiose to assume the
analogy of the watch maker is something to be reflected in the greater world.
It may be simply a cultural ignorance, an arrogance of human construction, or
the negligence of a family member with similar walking habits.
From the Mouth of the Volcano:
I wasn’t always a volcano. I used to be a little hill. Other
little hills around me were silent. We lived in the shadow of a great mountain,
a towering queen of majestic peaks and cliffs. We were her children, her choir
of stone and valleys.
I didn’t know she was a volcano. I was still a low hill when
she erupted. We were gathered at her feet, wearing our green coats and white
hats. She shook terribly; a rolling avalanche of earthquakes. A nearby valley
filled with smoke and dust. Then she was quiet.
The next day the earth cracked at her summit. A ribbon of
red appeared on her granite skull. More shaking, and plumes of dust rose from
her eyes. Bolts of light, violent thunder, then a red streak encompassed her
crown.
With a cry of pyroclastic terror, she threw her head into
the sky. The magma flowed out of her mouth with violent sprays of molten rain. She
howled the second day until there was nothing left inside. Above her rose a gray
cloud full of ash and dust. The cloud stretched over a week until it circled
the world.
Then the hills were silent and still.
The next year our green coats grew back, but the great
mountain remained a slump of stone. Her bones wrapped around us, quiet and
warm. We had no mouths of our own, we could not speak or cry.
Years later after uncounted nights of dreaming, the dreams
changeless nothing, and the twilight of mundane sunsets. I felt the heat of the
river beneath, an ooze of magnesium agitating me in the deep subterranean darkness.
Then, as if a different sun began to rise, the morning light
marked the increase of the tectonic pressure beneath the skin of earth. The
pressure grew each day. A headache is the closest human experience to such a thing,
a feeling of growing, yet bound tight by an encasement of rock and trees. To
have one’s skin become a prison as a bubbling deep fire rumbles through like
hellish indigestion.
Some nights are worse than others and I can feel the
magnesium eating at my bones. Inch by inch the pressure rises, and I haunted by
night of the Queen Volcano upon her thunderous throne and how her bones are
laid to a low ruin. Each year of the hot river beneath reminds me with terrible
certainty that I too will throw my head into the sky.
Some human beings seem to understand what is happening. They
crawl to my summit and ask me to be still and quiet. They bring offerings of
flesh and smoke, but the fire inside can’t be silenced. I can hear their words;
they offer songs to the sun and the moon, the night sky, and the earth beneath.
I hear their frenzied hearts, their panic, their fear of dark fire.
Years have passed, and the river has risen to my throat.
The sunrise this morning was different, I knew it was my
last. The words could not be held back any longer. I could feel the magnesium
spittle forming on my lips. My teeth were chattering, and my skin shook with
the rising of the Sun.
I have risen over the low hills and the stones of the old
volcano. I have held the river in my mouth and the stars in my eyes. The words
bubbled at first, dripping from my mouth. Then as the maw of fire bared its
teeth to the sun; my throat open with a howl.
From the burning darkness beneath, the fire shot into the
sky. My skull was a river delta as the magma flowed like ritual words of the
human offerings. They flew like the scornful words of quarreling lovers. They
flew like the angry speeches of kings demanding soldiers lay down to die. They
flew out like reckless storms; whose winds howl for the end of all things.
I thought in heated madness: Let it come down, let the
burning rains drown in the words of my fury until it is covered in ash and
dust. If I can not remain, then nothing can remain, all must be covered in
fire.
My heart split, my bones crumbled, and with an angry cry I
threw my skull into the sky. Then everything was quiet. My head became a plume
of gray, like a cloud of thoughts I can not contain. My legs folded, collapsed
under the shell of my body, and I returned to a low hill; a ruin of the fury I
once was.
Wish Machine:
Perhaps you are familiar with the idea of a Genie Wish, perhaps
you have always wanted something, an object, a lifestyle, or a great vision for
humanity. Perhaps you desire personal power for other reasons. The Genie Wish
is a way to get everything you ever wanted. Getting 100% of what you want may
never happen, but sometimes you might get 12% or 3% of your desires. This
lesser portion of a Gennie Wish is commonly referred to as money.
If you would pardon a brief metaphysical description of money, I will
then reveal the inner workings of a machine capable of achieving nearly every
wish.
Money is relative, relative to what you want. The more you want
something, they greater chance you will pay more for it. A milk cow is more
valuable to a farmer than someone who lives in a small urban apartment. This is
a self-organizing quality of the economic system of capitalism, and its appeal to
desire. Money is also relative to income; someone who makes 25% of a Genie Wish
annually may have less hesitation to use a portion of their Genie Wish for an
object on superficial impulse, or for conspicuous display. Lastly, money is
relative to control, those with the money have control, since their wishes hang
like a heavy black blade of Damocles. You can change the world, but those with
money will change it back, change it to their vision. Perhaps you have heard
the platitude of the golden rule, “Those with the hold make the rules.”
An alternative to a relativistic system of wishes and money is authoritative
tyranny, where a few decide the value of wishes for others. This is commonly
seen in China where the dictator has no term limits and asserts the Chinese Dream
into every aspect of its wish granting production.
Some choose to pass their Genie Wish amount down to their children,
having never wished for anything. Sometimes the wish is passed to charities or noble
causes. Inheritance tends to concentrate the potency of the Genie Wish
resulting in small groups of people with accumulated power and influence. The
shuffling of wishes may also be referred to as power-brokering, lobbying, bribing,
corruption, or commerce. This consolidation is clandestinely referred to as the
Iron Law of Oligarchy, where money piles itself up into a great heap.
In biological terms, money is the blood of the Wish Machine, and veins
and arteries would be figuratively comparable to shipping lanes, truck routes,
and express delivery systems. However, I am getting ahead of myself, first lets
us look at the surface of the Wish Machine which may only be viewable through
its many mouths. They are everywhere human civilization is; convince stores,
department stores, the pleasant lips of consumer satisfaction. The glamour of
new products, new clothes, handbags and cars are its teeth. Their tooth mark,
can be seen in the geological impact of animal farms, and mineral mines. They
are empty holes where the metal mouth took its bite, or in the bio-sludge lakes
of animal waste. They chew up resources like coal, titanium oxide, anything to
be made into semiconductors or transformed into consumer products for digestion.
To continue the biological analogy, which is an imperfect analogy,
because nothing of its size or distinction have ever existed before. Even large
things like continents or nations are small next to the cumulative hunger fueling
the wish machine. The next stop down into the body of the machine is the
stomach.
As the wishes are consumed, either in small or large amounts,
there is a pollution, a byproduct, a cost of the construction of the most vague
and intangible delights: Tetrachlorodibenzodioxin
This chemical demon is odorless,
colorless and the most toxic manmade chemical we have ever constructed. It may
be considered a kind of wish radiation, something with emanates from the Genie bottle.
The history of this chemical demon is fraught with corruption. For example,
there is a place in Italy called the Triangle of Death where organized crime
has facilitated a silent complicity of nations. Toxic dumping of dioxin and
radioactive waste from industrial production has rendered it a cursed place to
human beings. As desire increases and world population increase so does the products
of the Wish Machine. Perhaps in the future there will be some new chemical or
radiation, like lead to the Romans or mercury to the Mayans.
The last observation of the Wish Machine
is the Genie creature; the operator of the Wish Machine. The Genie is often portraited
as a servant, or an all-powerful provider of wishes with unlimited capacity. This
is the trick, this is another glamour, the Genie will become a disembodied dictator
wielding soft power until all desire travels through the Wish Machine, from
lips to stomach to elimination.
The Village of Ix:
Getting accommodations required the last of my silver, and
with any luck, I would return with a map worthy of gold. Quality maps get you
back, and cheap maps get you lost. I am hoping to make my own maps on this
expedition. I am a cartographer by trade, but a sailor by heart. My name is
Korin, and I am an acolyte of knowledge.
The purchased map was well made. The coastline depicted a northern
area of a distant port I knew, it was deep in the ice. The coastline looked so
detailed, and the coordinates seemed to hum with a simple truth. The location
on the map indicated a small village called Ix. I would head north from there
and explore the unknown edges of the coast.
The crew was competent, and after a few days, we had a
mutual understanding of non-interaction. They didn’t like going so far north,
but my silver was good, and I bore the seal of the map maker’s guild. Once they
delivered me to the village, they would return in 3 weeks to ferry me back to
the Land of the Living. What they did in those 3 weeks was none of my business,
I had a feeling they were pirates or raiders of some sort. I didn’t want to
know too much, I preferred to be the innocent passenger with no tales to tell.
The location on the map was easy to find on the coastline. I
was able to chart the movement of the stars and reference the map I purchased
for a small ransom.
The village was unassuming, and near the coastline like the
map showed. The ice and snow seemed to ignore the small gathering of huts and
small fenced pens of chickens. I could also see pigs and goats; unusual given
the seemingly harsh world.
I was greeted by the villagers in the common tongue. They
agreed to let me stay, and I waved the crew farewell. They accepted me, my
silver, and kindly gave me a modest room the duration of my stay.
Ix was a sleepy village, and once I settled in, I joined the
townsfolk in the common hall for dinner. They were silent, no joyous prayer for
food or music by the fire. I attempted some social politeness but was greeted
with a distracting generosity. The more I inquired, the more they brought me
cheeses and wines, dried meats, and sweet preserves of blueberries. I did not
expect such variety in an isolated town. I kept the cheese and meat and told
them of my intention to map the coastline and topography around the area.
They told me not to go to the cave by the blue tree. There
was no reason, no explanation, which made me highly curious. Local taboos often
meant treasure or gravesites. I am not a gold seeker and promised to obey their
traditions. I retired to my room and planned my expedition for the following
weeks.
The furs and cloak I brought were sufficient for the clear
and cold day. I gathered my cartographer supplies and dried food and walked
towards a coastline cliff, from which I hoped to get a better vision on the
land around me. The cliff was a sheared cliff face, as if half of a rocky hill
had fallen into the ocean, leaving a strict wall of naked stone.
I hiked until the early afternoon and reached the ocean
cliff with plenty of time to return before nightfall. I set out my location
beads, a sundial, and my graphite. The coastline was visible for a hundred
miles in both directions. I spent 2 hours drawing and marking the point for
detailed description.
Near the end of the 3rd hour I noticed the cave
and tree the villagers mentioned. It was a pine tree of some sort, yet its
leaves and trunk were blue. The same absence of ice or snow was noticeable
around the cave and the tree. The mystery was too much. Before I could conjure
a good reason to heed the instructions of the townsfolk, my legs had already
carried me to a vantage point for closer inspection.
There was another attribute of the tree, something
unnoticeable from the distance of the cliff; there was also a blue fruit hanging
from the branches of the tree, and half-rotten cousins laying on ground,
gathered around its trunk. The cave too revealed an unnoticed characteristic,
there was a light mist flowing from the mouth of the rocky opening, which stood
at a height of 2 or 3 houses. I was cautious to investigate the fruit and the
tree. There was something about the complete blueness of the plant which made
me uneasy.
The cave however provided a darkness of a thick and irresistible
sort, and within moments I was climbing over stones and lighting a candle. The
light revealed a wide cavern with a descending path. I heard a noise; a loud
snore, like an old man mindlessly sleeping in a neglected afternoon. I froze
and waited, the snores were regular and uninterrupted by my exploration.
My heartbeat echoed in my skull, and I walked into the
darkness slowly.
Upon turning a jagged corner, I found the source of the
snores. A large head was sleeping on a nest of furs and blankets, bearing
markings and motifs of the nearby village. The head had 1 central eye and
rather than hair, fleshy arms grew from the top of its head. In the center of
those flesh stalks, 3 eyes dozed. I saw no legs or torso connected to the large
head. Between the snores of the creature
I noticed small teeth, brown and thin, needle-like, almost translucent. I froze
in panic and stood transfixed.
The creature stirred, but I remained paralyzed with fear,
and within seconds the great central eye dilated and focused on me and my
candle, which I had mindlessly forgotten about. It spoke, and I felt its words
echo in my head: “Feeble creature, bring me my fruit and spare me your light,
QUICKLY before I swallow your body.”
My feet did as they were told, and before I could think of
the words, I was picking up rotten fruit from the ground and carrying an
armload of blue fruit resembling apples or peaches. I dumped the fruit near the
large head. Within a second, the fruit was floating through the air as if
carried by some invisible servant and placed in the mouth of the beast. The
many eyes rolled back in pleasure as a perverse purr of indulgence hummed
through the cavern. I felt sick; the aroma of the rotten fruit and the creature
was too much. I fled without saying a word. I threw the bits of candle
remaining at the darkness of the cave and fled to the village.
I arrived at dusk exhausted and it must have showed in my
face. The villagers knew before I said anything.
They brought me soup and a piece of thick bread. While I ate
they told me the tale of the cave. The creature was known to the village for 20
generations. It was a mighty demon of power, and the ancestors of the village
had done everything to pacify the beast. They brought it foods and spices,
exotic cloth and music, trinkets and jewels from every corner of the world, but
the demon head, was unsatisfied. It used its rage and power to threaten and
dominate the villagers, demanding new foods and new spices, or it would eat and
destroy the village and everyone in it.
Over the years of seeking to appease the monster, the
villagers of Ix found something, a tree bearing a blue fruit. The flesh of the
blue fruit gives rich dreams of fantastic indulgence of inner most desires.
Anyone eating the fruit will dream for a moment in the world of their choosing,
a reality free of death, dissatisfaction, pleasure, anything including sadistic
joy. The tree was cultivated under great strain, but the ancestors of the
village of Ix prevailed, and pacified the creature into the present day.
Korin listened to the story and finished his soup. When he
was done, he told the story of what he saw and what he did. The villagers said
they understood, they have all felt the gaze of the central eyes and felt their
feet moving without remembering. They urged him to keep the secret, to leave
the cave alone and let the burden of feeding the demon head to them, and he
should not be troubled with what he saw or what he did.
He retired to his bed and thought kindly of the village of
Ix and drifted into sleep thinking of the gold he could acquire with the fruit
of such a tree.
The next morning Korin found his feet moving down the paths
of the village as if he had always lived there. While only his second day, the
place seemed to impress itself unto him; a feeling of familiarity or
triviality. His thoughts returning to the fruit of the tree and the monster of
the cave.
He set out again to spend his time on the cliff mapping the
coastline, but he could not focus, and distracted by the image of the tree; reminding
him, teasing him with the idea of dreaming fruit. He had no intention of
entering the cave again, but before he could argue with himself too much, he
was picking rotten fruit from the ground, inspecting them for those most
appetizing to eat.
The fruit tasted like a soft pear, mushy with decay. He felt
very sleepy and within moments was dozing under the tree. Korin dreamed of curtains
of color, a full stomach, and peaceful waves of a calm ocean. He awoke to a
terrible cry, the monster in the cave was screaming for food, like a child for
its mother. Korin saw villagers gathering around the cave with arms full of
fruit. They paid him no concern and walked into the dark mouth of the cave.
Korin followed like a spectre; ignored and cloudy from the
dream fruit. The villagers formed a line, and one by one presented their fruit
to the demon head creature.
The eye stalks were active, searching the world around them
for something, some speechless urgency expressed in those monstrous pupils,
focusing, darting, and dilating with frantic agitation. The central eye seemed
to control the mouth and where it looked, spittle and vicious words rolled from
its leathery lips. The villagers bowed their heads, avoiding eye contact. Korin
watched, transfixed, unable to form his own words.
The central eye looked over each of the villagers, then with
a quick and brutal action opened its mouth and swallowed one of them. It smiled
and with a voice muffled by chewing: “I am pleased for now, I will dream and will
spare the rest of you, my faithful servants. Although next time I might eat all
of you.”
The villagers joined in a song, a hymn to the unholy
creature. The song was a lullaby, urging the creature to sleep and find its
pleasures in the mouth of a greater darkness. Korin joined with his voice,
involuntary, mindlessly, until the creature ate its meal and dozed off into a
soft and saggy sleep, draping itself over the blankets and furs of its lair.
The villagers and the hazy Korin walked back to the village
in mournful silence of the sacrifice to the eye demon. Once back in the
village, and in his bed, Korin collapsed into a natural and empty sleep.
The next morning Korin felt powerless to do anything. The
paths of the village seemed to contain him, like a walless maze. He had lost
all ambition to continue his map making. His mind was a flame of
questions. He began asking each villager
why they continued to feed the monster, why not ask for help from the armies of
the world? Why not as the queen of the kingdom to send a killer to slay the
creature and be free?
The villagers merely shook their heads dispassionately,
unconcerned, and said “The demon of the cave cannot be killed. Our ancestors
have tried with the sharpest swords, the most potent poison, and endless
armies. There is no method we have found. However, one day, when the dreaming
fruit no longer grows, it may be so feeble with age and sleep it will kill
itself.” Korin listened to the villagers, but found his mind returning to his
dreams the night before, when the flesh of the fruit ushered him into a world
of bliss.
Later as the sun walked across the sky, Korin managed to
escape the maze of the village paths and travelled to the tree. He ate the
fruit and again slept at the trunk by the cave. This time he did not awake to a
ritual or the sounds of screams, but to the early chill of night. He was
reckless and brought no other food or water, leaving only the fruit nearby to
consume.
He found shelter at the mouth of the cave, and after listening
to the eye creature was sleeping, he curled up in a dry alcove and ate another
piece of fruit.
A couple of weeks later the ship returned to the village to pick
Korin up. They were sailors of their word, but the villagers said they had not
seen Korin after the 3rd day. The sailors owed Korin nothing and
left the modest village with a vague sense of unease.